S Korea complains to WTO about China over Thaad

A sign is displayed outside a golf course being used as the site for the recently installed US Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) system, in Seongju on March 18, 2017.Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

The US THAAD missile system being deployed in South Korea has angered China

South Korea has appealed to the World Trade Organization to determine if the Chinese government is treating South Korean companies unfairly.

Seoul claims Beijing is retaliating economically over its deployment of a US anti-missile defence system.

South Korea’s Trade Minister Joo Hyung-hwan told parliament China “may be in violation of some trade agreements”.

China opposes the deployment, saying it will affect the regional security balance and allow the US to spy on it.

Washington and Seoul say the Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (Thaad) system is designed to protect against threats from North Korea. But it has caused significant tension with China, which is South Korea’s largest trading partner.

“The Chinese government may not admit that they took retaliatory measures against the Thaad decision, but we have to point out the possibility,” Mr Joo said according to Yonhap news agency.

“We are collecting evidence and will also deal with issues that South Korean companies are treated unfairly in China.”

South Korea complained about China to the WTO over the issue on Friday, Mr Joo said.

What is the Terminal High Altitude Area Defense System (Thaad)?

  • Shoots down short and medium-range ballistic missiles in the terminal phase of their flight
  • Uses hit-to-kill technology – where kinetic energy destroys the incoming warhead
  • Has a range of 200km and can reach an altitude of 150km
  • US has previously deployed it in Guam and Hawaii as a measure against potential attacks from North Korea

What impact will S Korea’s expanded missile defence system have?

China’s leaders have voiced serious displeasure over the Thaad system and its deployment has generated anti-South Korean sentiment.

The row has coincided with a number of economic measures being imposed on South Korea.

China’s National Tourism Administration ordered local travel agencies to stop selling tour packages to South Korea starting 15 March, according to Korea’s Tourism Organisation.

“Some estimates suggest that Beijing’s travel ban could reduce the number of Chinese visitors to South Korea by up to 70%, resulting in billions of dollars in lost tourism-related revenue,” Scott Seaman, director of Asia at the Eurasia Group, said.

China froze the sale and distribution of some South Korean television dramas, music and products starting last October. Nearly all shows or music concerts starring Korean artists have been suspended.

Chinese authorities have also closed dozens of stores belonging to South Korea’s Lotte Group, which has signed a deal to provide land to host the Thaad system, for allegedly violating safety regulations.

China denies the recent moves are related to the Thaad deployment.

In a separate development, the Lotte Group’s 93-year-old founder and three other family members went on trial in Seoul on Monday for alleged embezzlement, tax evasion and fraud.

Tong Zhao, a fellow from the Carnegie-Tsinghua Center for Global Policy, believes China’s economic pressure may ultimately prove counter-productive.

“Threats of economic sanctions are part of coercive diplomacy, but they may not be useful in addressing the Thaad issue,” he wrote in a 2016 report.

“These forceful measures would likely be seen as a sign of disrespect and a direct threat to South Korea’s interests – which could ultimately push South Korea to bolster its military alliance with the United States”.

S Korea complains to WTO about China over Thaad}